Planning your investments
“Expect the best, plan for the worst, and prepare to be surprised." - Denis
Waitley
Why is planning important?
Planning is an essential part
of investing. Planning not only brings in an element of discipline into the
investing process but also helps investors better understand their own
objectives, needs, unique constraints and risk tolerance.
Most High Net Worth
Individuals (HNIs) have written documents called Investment Policy Statements
(IPSs) outlining their investment objectives, risk tolerance and the methods
that their portfolio managers should use to achieve those objectives. Strategic
Asset Allocation, tax constraints and liquidity constraints are clearly
mentioned in an IPS.
Prudent individual investors
would do well to create such written documents for themselves.
The key steps in creating an investment
plan are as follows:
1. Always plan on paper
It helps to have a written
plan as opposed to a vague mental note. Not only does this bring clarity but it
also becomes useful when you want to refer to your plan in future.
2. Outline your investment
objectives
Investors should outline your
long term investment objectives in detail. What sort of returns would investor
like over the long run? Can the investor bear the requisite risk? Common long
term objectives are:
Capital preservation: Capital preservation implies
that the investor’s aim is to maintain the purchasing power of his capital,
given an inflation rate and to not lose money through risky investments. This is
usually the aim of investors with a low risk appetite such as retirees. Good
instruments for capital preservation are Treasury bonds, Inflation linked
securities such as TIPS, money market instruments and high quality corporate
bonds.
Capital appreciation: Investors whose aim is
capital appreciation aim to grow their money. This is usually achieved though
increases in the value of their investments. Several investors aim to achieve
capital appreciation over long time horizons. This is a common objective among
investors with moderate to high risk appetite.
Regular Income: Quite a few investors seek
regular income payouts from them investments. This income usually comes from
interest (bond coupons etc) and dividends. Of course, it is possible for
investors to create their own dividend by selling part of their holdings that
have appreciated in value.
3. Understand and document
your risk tolerance
It is critical for investors
to understand both their capacity to take risk and their willingness to take
risk. It is important to understand the distinction between the two. Investors
can invest in risky assets as part of a diversified portfolio if they are both
willing and able to accept risk.
The ability to take on risk
depends on several factors such as net worth, age, liquidity requirements, long
term goals and mental make-up of the investor. More information on assessing the
risk tolerance of investors can be found here.
Whatever be the risk
tolerance of the investors, it should be documented and taken into account while
making investing decisions.
4. Outline your needs and
constraints
Investors often have special
needs and constraints? Investors should document them and take them into account
while making investment decisions. Preferences with respect to asset classes or
securities are considerations that should be taken into account while planning.
5. Understand your tax
implications
Tax management can
significantly enhance investment returns. This is especially important for
investors with high marginal tax rates (the tax rate on every additional dollar
of income earned). Investing in tax exempt accounts or tax deferred accounts
such as retirement accounts could be considered. Deferring the realization of
capital gains, investing in tax-exempt securities such as certain Federal
government bonds, municipal bonds etc are other strategies that can be
considered. When comparing two similar investments, decisions should be made on
after-tax returns and not pre-tax returns.
5. Work on Asset Allocation
Asset Allocation is the
process by which the investor decides how much is to be invested in each asset
class. Asset allocation depends heavily on the investor’s objectives, risk
profile and individual preferences. Equities and real estate instruments are
risky but offer high returns. Most fixed income securities barring junk bonds
tend to give low but stable returns. Government bonds yield the least but are
the safest securities.
It is wise to diversify
across asset classes and across different securities within an asset class. This
reduces the volatility of returns to some extent. Also try to choose assets
which are not well correlated with each other. For example, Oil and Gold are not
well correlated. Therefore, am Oil ETF may make a good addition to a portfolio
heavily weighted with a Gold tracking ETF.
It is impractical to expect
large returns despite investing in low risk assets. For a rough idea of the kind
of returns that can be expected in the long from different asset classes, refer
to the following table. Needless to say, these are just rough estimates of long
term expected returns.
|
Assets
|
Expected long term returns
|
|
Diversified portfolio of large cap equities in Developed economies
|
10-12% p.a.
|
|
Diversified portfolio of large cap equities in Emerging economies
|
10-15% p.a.
|
|
Diversified portfolio of small
cap equities in Developed economies
|
12-16% p.a.
|
|
Gold
|
8-10% p.a.
|
|
High quality corporate bonds(Depends on prevailing rates)
|
3-5% p.a.
|
|
Money Market instruments(Depends on prevailing rates)
|
1-4% p.a.
|
|
Treasury Securities(Depends on prevailing rates)
|
1-5% p.a.
|
6.Plan your response to
unexpected changes in market conditions
Investment returns can be
volatile, especially over the short-medium run. Try to plan your response ahead
of time. At what price will you exit your investment position? What time horizon
do you have in mind for each investment? How much of a decline in the value of
your investment can you bear before you sell? All these are questions that you
should ask yourself before making an investment.
Investors who stick to the
fundamental rules such as these tend do well in the long run. Remember,
investing involves planning and patience.
Summary of an example plan
- Victor
Zhukovsky is a 24 year old Computer Engineer residing in
Ithaca,
USA with an annual income of US$ 75,000. He
enjoys adventure sports and traveling around the world. He seeks long term
capital appreciation from his portfolio worth $50,000. His willingness to take
on risk is high.
- Victor
needs $20,000 in January 2014 to pay for his tuition fees for a graduate program
in Business Management that he plans to attend at a state university in USA.
- He also needs $10,000 to go on a tour of
South America in January 2010.
- Victor is
taxed at approx 24% by the United and 7.5% by the New York State Government. In
order not to exacerbate his tax burden, all debt instruments in his portfolio
should be either Federal, State or Municipal debt unless the after tax yield of
the alternate debt instrument is greater than the yield of the equivalent
tax-free debt instrument.
- His
investments should appreciate at a minimum 5-year average rate of 15% p.a.
subject to a maximum decline of 20% between any 2 consecutive years and 10% in
any given 5-year period.
-
Not more
than 90% and not less than 50% of the portfolio may be allocated to equities at
any given point of time with the sole exception of the times when the Dow Jones
Industrial Average falls by more than 20% in the preceding three months.
- Victor is
strongly against the use of tobacco and thus, none of his portfolio companies
may be directly involved in the production, processing or distribution of
tobacco/tobacco products.
Next: Opening a Trading Account